Is the Indian Parliament Losing its Relevance?

Image for Is the Parliament losing relevance_4Pandemonium, bedlam and pell-mell – such is the terminology used by the mainstream media to describe the proceedings in the Indian Parliament that has lately become more a place of sound and fury than one of sensible discussions and sedate action, which it used to be till not very long ago. Intermittent light-hearted banter and bonhomie, which used to mark serious discussions between the opposition and ruling party members on the floor of the Parliament, now seem to have given way to a frosty chill between the two. Nor is there the traditional camaraderie of the past any longer to bind the lawmakers of conflicting ideological orientations together in the name of their common avowed goal of service to the nation.

Palpable is the animus between groups of members who seem to be intent on settling political scores on the floor of the legislature and those who are serious about legislation. A healthy rivalry between the members to bring about radical changes, by means of legislation, to the existing conditions that impede the nation’s advancement and progress, seems to have given way to personal animosity and party-based claims of monopoly over honourable intentions to serve the nation. Ideological differences never seemed perilously sharper and more pronounced in the past than they are now. In both the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha, the well of the House has become the scene of frenetic action where honourable members converge to demonstrate their lung power.

Over the smallest of differences in matters and issues of tremendous significance and importance to the nation, dissenting members jump to their feet, rush to the well, wave a fistful of papers in the air and vie for the attention of the Chair. In the process, the arguments of the members who introduce bills and those who support the bills are drowned. The upshot of the ensuing bedlam is the stalling of the session and the staging of political drama. Over some perceived injustice or other meted out to a member of the opposition albeit outside the Parliament or the unwillingness of the ruling party to accede to the opposition’s demand for the ouster of a minister or disciplinary action against a member of the ruling party, entire sections of the opposition stage a walk out.

In winter session 2015, disruptions were caused on account of excuses such as the raging nationwide debate on intolerance, alleged political vendetta of the government against Congress President Sonia Gandhi and her deputy Rahul Gandhi in the National Herald case and alleged involvement of Finance Minister Arun Jaitley in what the Aam Aadmi Party claimed were corrupt deals of the Delhi and District Cricket Association. In the monsoon session of 2015, disruptions were caused by the opposition parties seeking the ouster of External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj and Chief Ministers Vasundhara Raje and Shivraj Singh Chauhan. In such an oft-repeated scenario, healthy debates become well nigh impossible. When emotions rule the roost, reason takes a back seat, and the Parliament becomes dysfunctional. With the lawmakers being hardly inclined to pass bills and enact laws, people who elected them to carry out the onerous task cannot help wondering if the colossal amounts of money being spent by the nation on the holding of the sessions are worth the exercise since it does not serve the intended purpose of the legislation.

Disruptions Galore

The winter session of the Parliament that ended recently is a case in point. The functioning of the two Houses is a study in contrast. The Lok Sabha had 20 sittings, worked extra hours, scored 100.46% in terms of the number of hours it functioned and passed 14 bills. The Rajya Sabha, on the other hand, worked 60 hours and scored barely 46%. It lost as many as 47 hours in disruptions and passed a mere nine bills. In the words of the Chairman of the Upper House, the just-concluded  Rajya Sabha session seemed “singularly unproductive in terms of legislative work” and had “redeemed itself somewhat” in the last three days. Expressing distress over repeated disruptions, he called upon the members of the House to “introspect on this state of affairs” and to abstain from practices and approaches that lower the stature of the Rajya Sabha.

Since a functioning legislature is an essential concomitant of the principles of the Constitution to which the members are committed, and disruptions of the sessions negate these principles, recourse to disruptions for stalling the sessions is in violation of the spirit of the Constitution and commitment of members to that sacred text of the premier democratic institution of our country. Furthermore, since the rulings and repeated exhortations of the Chair to the members for observing decency and decorum are ignored during such interruptions, they tend to lower the dignity of the House in public perception.

Tyranny of the Minority

The legislation was no cakewalk in Lok Sabha either. The Lower House also witnessed vociferous members of the principal opposition party trooping to the well of the House time and again in a bid to stall the proceedings. It was in spite of such not-too-infrequent disruptions that the House saved the day by working overtime to pass bills. The Parliamentary Affairs Minister described the repeated attempts of the opposition parties to cause disruptions and stall proceedings in the Lower House as “tyranny of the minority”.

The principal casualty of the non-functioning of either House of the Parliament is legislation. The frosty winter session of 2015 had the dubious distinction of seeing the lowest number of bills passed since the winter session of 2010. As part of an apparently well-thought-out strategy conceived even before the session begins, the opposition parties, which do not have sufficient numbers, try to stall the proceedings by causing repeated disruptions. The ruling party bills and private member bills become casualty alike.

During the zero hour, members find themselves unable to raise questions that impinge on the nation in general and their constituencies in particular. In the case of lapses and failures in the implementation of policies, it becomes impossible for members to hold the Establishment and their political masters responsible. Out of the nine bills cleared by the Rajya Sabha in the just-concluded session, four were passed on the last day without discussion. How truly representative and meaningful would be the laws that are passed without discussion albeit for want of time?

Image for Is the Parliament losing relevanceWhy the Disruptions?

Why do political parties resort to disruptions in our Parliament?  The answer lies in the answer to a counter question, namely, what do these parties gain out of a stalled session? Evidently, the opposition parties want, out of spite, to paralyze the Parliament and reduce the ruling party’s ability to get crucial bills passed for implementation of their policies and programs. Such an eventuality would inevitably result in stagnation of developmental work promised by the ruling party in its pre-poll campaigns. Out of peevishness, cussedness and callous disregard to the development and progress of the nation, the opposition parties engage in such counter-productive activities albeit through means, which are on face value not inadmissible in terms of the parliamentary rules and norms.

Money No Consideration!

It costs the exchequer Rs 2.5 lakh per minute to conduct a parliament session, which translates into a loss of Rs 1.5 crore for every wasted hour. Our Rajya Sabha lost 47 hours in the winter session this year, causing the nation a loss of Rs 70.5 crore, which is indeed a lot of money for an earful of gobbledygook! This is nothing but taxpayers’ money going up in smoke to the accompanying cacophony of the protesters!

Malice and Methodology

Colossal amounts of money have thus been lost in session after session of washed-up parliamentary proceedings, which add up to missed opportunities to pass much-needed legislation of crucial bills like the General Services and Tax (GST) Bill, Land Acquisition Bill, etc. And the mainstream media (MSM) has been ranting and raving about the insensitivity of the lawmakers to the need of the hour, which is to shore up the gains of economic reforms the common man’s way. Every move proposed by the government to introduce economic reforms is a backup measure to vindicate in legislative terms Prime Minister Modi’s repeated assurances to potential foreign investors about the nation’s preparedness to welcome them to do business in India. Every such wasted opportunity is a setback to our nation’s goal of expanding the parameters of its economic policy for the purpose of pitchforking business opportunities in modern India to international standards.

Meanwhile, the whole world has been waiting to see how Prime Minister Modi captures the mood of the nation and garners its collective preparedness to upgrade India’s economy to a higher level. The world’s expectations and the nation’s hopes have been repeatedly belied not on account of a lack of merit of the case, but on account of lack of fortitude on the part of some elected representatives who do not deem it fit to subjugate their own personal or party’s agenda to the common good of the nation. Another wasted session, another dream dashed to the ground! After ten years of misgovernance by a scam-ridden coalition that seemed totally fazed in the face of the daunting tasks ahead and was hopelessly immobilized, the people had voted en masse for a party that spoke the refreshing language of developmental politics and hoped for a breakthrough in the impasse the country had found itself in.

What has ensued is only a valiant jump from the political quagmire to a logjam in the Parliament! The opposition parties, led by Congress, obviously could not reconcile to their collective defeat in the 2014 Lok Sabha elections. Hence, they seem determined to sabotage the attempts of the NDA government to stabilize itself by means of good governance. Narendra Modi’s successful foreign policy forays and the consequent worldwide goodwill and support for his landmark initiatives, especially on the economic front, from leading economic powers as well as the extremely positive forecasts from the international rating agencies, corporate giants and business honchos, have had their unintended share of exacerbating the sense of acrimony on the part of opposition parties against Narendra Modi and his government.

Unable to pin a single charge of corruption or scam on Modi, these parties, with the Congress and the AAP at the vanguard, have been relentless in their attempt to rain on the Modi government’s parade. Hence, the uproar and ruckus on their part to hold up the Parliament! Their immediate takeaway of the stalemate in the Parliament is government’s inability to usher in economic reforms and score international acclaim as well as approbation from the people of the country. They are wishful of a bigger takeaway in the medium and long terms, namely, the opprobrium not unlikely to sidle up Modi’s international image by his ‘inability’ to carry the conflicting political forces of the nation together and ensure the successful functioning of the Parliament. Every bill passed by the ordinance channel would be held up against him as a chink in his armour. This would further bolster the charge of the opposition regarding their claims of searing levels of intolerance in the country.

Suffice it to say that Modi would be alienated more and more from the gullible sections of the masses, foreign governments and international business circles looking for lucrative openings for investments in a stable country that promises conducive economic and business climate, free from political bickering notwithstanding possible political upheavals in the country in the future. What better way to depict a nation in unflattering colours as a failed state than by painting its Parliament as a hostile and truncated law-making body and the Prime Minister as a partisan leader incapable of carrying progressive political forces along?  That the image of the nation is bound to be castigated in the process is apparently immaterial and of no consequence to those who resort to the tactics of interruptions.

Reforms and Relevance

Consider the already dented image of the beleaguered Indian Parliament, which has been rendered dormant, in contrast to the House of Commons in Britain. The latter takes pride in its claim of having lost not a single day in any of the sessions in its long history. In the case of the Indian Parliament, any further damage to its battered image is likely to cause further dismay among the people of the country and accelerate the process of attrition of their faith in the efficacy of the legislature. Reforms to set the Parliament back on the rail is the need of the hour. Timely action to introduce reforms to strengthen the due role of the Parliament is crucial for the healthy growth of Indian democracy. The reforms should be based on the bedrock of the dictum that legislation is the raison d’être of the Parliament and the assemblage of the honourable members of the august body. Failure to carry out this onerous responsibility due to the tactics of some members should be viewed seriously. There is already a nagging doubt engaging the people’s mind regarding the need and usefulness of the Upper House, members of which are not directly elected by the masses.

There have been silent talks of considering presidential system of government in India where the executive wing will be independent of the legislative. Dr. Shashi Tharoor has also recently talked about the recommendation of one of the members of the Simon Commission for presidential system for India; to this the then leaders of the INC did not respond favorably. It is sure that if the makers of the constitutions and even the then members of the Indian National Congress would have envisaged such disrespect to the parliamentary system, they would have given a second thought to the system of governance. In the upcoming budget session, the Congress and other opposition parties are yet again equipped with the Arunachal Pradesh’s President Rule issue, which they will make a matter of alleged intolerance on the part of the ruling government. A recent survey conducted by one of the national new channels has depicted that the people of India view the Congress as the one to blame for the ongoing brouhaha and resultant legislative and economic defeat of the country. It is time for Congress and its partners to realize the same. Also is the time apt to think over either a fortified parliamentary system or take a tougher route of deliberating presidential system of government for India.

There is currently a proposal receiving the Government’s consideration to grant a hundred percent hike in the salary of the honourable members of Parliament. The proposal further envisages enhancement in the other allowances and perks. All this should be linked to the good work that the lawmakers are supposed to do albeit in the service of the nation. Failure to work should entail a loss in pecuniary benefits. There should also be a system to monitor the persistent behavioral pattern of the members not conducive to the work culture. Further thought should be given by experts to hold the honourable members accountable for their performance, or the lack of it, and answerable to the people. Unless such drastic redressal measures are brought about, without any further delay, to make our Parliament infallible, the relevance of the august body will only become more and more of a subject matter of a growing sense of skepticism and cynicism in public perception. After three long decades the people of India gave the requisite majority backing to the Modi-led government, disrupting its functioning and reforms agenda is an evident murder of people’s aspirations.

101 thoughts on “Is the Indian Parliament Losing its Relevance?

  1. Debasish Dhar

    No one has seen such bad performance by any parliament in its lifetime what India is witnessing these days. No use of voting Congress out of power if they have the power to hold reforms. Sad time for the countrymen.

    Reply
  2. Gireesh Shakywar

    The entire country knows that opposition is disrupting the parliament by crying over pity issues which have no relevance for the development of India. Next time this opposition will see no seat in Parliament, this is sure.

    Reply
  3. J.P.DHOOT

    We are most unfortunate to have such irresponsible opposition party in parliament.Parliament is run by parliamentarians and the public in general is a mere spectator but how long?Some change in legislation is urgent to run the system.

    Reply
  4. Kamal Gotte

    If Congress has some issues over GST then why cant the BJP listen to that. BJP is an arrogant party of men who want to impose there autocratic ruling inside and outside the Lok Sabha. Modi has failed on this count and he needs to learn teamplay.

    Reply
  5. Abhishek Malhotra

    Now the Congress will never talk of presidential system because they do not have a leader like Indira or Rajeev. Only BJP has strong leaders hence they will ask for this form of governance. If this succeeds, Modi will be the President.

    Reply
  6. Mehul Bhadani

    Is there no way that the courts can direct our MPs to hold constructive sessions? They relish our money and wasting such crucial time designated for law making is sheer abuse of power.

    Reply
  7. Param Dhanoa

    True, India needs a reworking on rules over conduct of Lok Sabha sessions and until this happens both BJP and congress will fight when not in power. The only losers in this fight is the common man of India.

    Reply
  8. Ramesh Raja

    It is very sad that PM Modi talks about GST, land bill and smart cities in parliament. Where are farmers in his plan of action? Where are poor children and unprivileged households in his reforms agenda?

    Reply
  9. uday mathe

    Atat Bihari Vajpayee was a brilliant politician in this regard. He had good rapport with opposition parties, Narendra Modi lacks that talent. He should start talking to leaders like Rahul Gandhi, Mamta Banerjee and Jayalalitha for getting their support.

    Reply
  10. sunil Mohanty

    Dismantle Rajya Sabha and give all powers only to the lower house. Because RS members are not directly elected they have no right to disturb the chosen government. This is our fundamental right and supreme court should act on this.

    Reply
  11. Harsh Chhatwani

    Your article will surely be a great help to a lot of people. An outstanding blend of thinking and good writing.

    Reply
  12. Palash Siddamsettiwar

    Hi there everyone, it is my first go to see at this site, and piece of writing is genuinely fruitful in favor of me, keep up posting these types of content.

    Reply
  13. Vikas Khanna

    I wish to say that this article is amazing, nice written and come with approximately all important infos. I would like to see more posts like this .

    Reply
  14. Bhawyen Mehta

    it is an amazing piece of writing designed for all the online visitors. they will get benefit from it I am sure.

    Reply
  15. Sahil Sankalp

    Thanks for your marvelous posting! I definitely enjoyed reading it, you might be a great author. I will be sure to bookmark your blog and will often come back very soon. I want to encourage you continue your great writing, have a nice evening!

    Reply
  16. Bharat Paliwal

    This excellent website really has all the info I wanted concerning this subject and did not know who to ask.

    Reply
  17. Pranav Hegde

    Greetings. Very useful advice in this particular post. it is the little changes which will make the most important changes.Thanks for sharing.

    Reply
  18. Ganesh kalia

    Quality articles or reviews is the key to attract the users to go to see the web site, that is what this web page is providing.

    Reply
  19. Verma ravishanker

    After looking into a handful of the blog articles on your website, I seriously like your technique of writing a blog. I added it to my bookmark site list and will be checking back in the near future.

    Reply
  20. Sajeevan Nair

    I recently had a good fortune of reading your article it is really well written with updated information. I will be returning here often now.

    Reply
  21. Nikhil Marathi

    Thank you, I have just been looking for info about this subject for ages and yours is the best I have found out till now.

    Reply
  22. Tanea Bandyopadhyay

    It is hard to find experienced people for this subject, but you seem like you know what you are talking about.

    Reply
  23. Ananth Shrma

    Very soon this web page will be famous among all blogging and site-building users, due to it is pleasant articles

    Reply
  24. Isha Chitnis

    I visit daily a few web sites and sites to read articles or reviews, however this blog provides feature based articles.

    Reply
  25. Niraj Kaushik

    Can I just say what a relief to discover someone that actually understands what they are talking about over the internet. You definitely understand how to bring a problem to light and make it important. More and more people really need to read this and understand this side of the story. I was surprised that you aren’t more popular since you most certainly possess the gift.

    Reply
  26. Naresh Mohanty

    Hi, I do believe this is an excellent web site. I stumbledupon it. Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and continue to help others.

    Reply
  27. Ramen Mukherjee

    Great web site you have got here.. it is difficult to find high-quality writing like yours nowadays. I truly appreciate people like you. Take care..

    Reply
  28. Himanshu Phirke

    The website is bright, clean, quick, easily navigable and all the links seem to work well. Moreover, the contents here in blog shape is really wonderful.

    Reply
  29. Jaswinder Singh

    Hi there to every one, it is in fact a fastidious for me to go to see this website, it includes important Information.

    Reply
  30. Sudhir salvi

    I wanted to thank you for this fantastic read.. I absolutely enjoyed every bit of it. I have got you book marked to check out new stuff you post

    Reply
  31. Vaibhav Pathak

    If some one wishes to be updated with most recent technologies therefore he must be pay a quick visit this site and be up to date all the time.

    Reply
  32. Yogender Raj

    Great blog you have got here.. it is difficult to find high quality writing like yours these days. I truly appreciate people like you. Take care..

    Reply
  33. Mangesh sardessai

    I read this article completely about the comparison of most up-to-date and preceding technologies, it is remarkable article.

    Reply
  34. Lakshmi Priya

    Hello there. This blog post could not be written much better. Going through this article reminds me of my previous roommate. He constantly kept talking about this. I will send this information to him. Fairly certain he will have a very good read. I appreciate you for sharing.

    Reply
  35. Manu Gokhale

    I am sure this piece of writing has touched all the internet viewers, its really really pleasant article on building up new weblog.

    Reply
  36. Lavanya Rajput

    I just had to drop you a line to let you know that John and I think that the website is BRILLIANT……………………… Well done.

    Reply
  37. Bhavin Desai

    See only those who listen to news and read newspapers know that congress is the one to blame for parliament ruckus. Those who just want to see results will blame ruling government after end of five years for unproductive sessions.

    Reply
  38. Ujjwal Kalia

    Hello. I simply want to give you a huge thumbs up for the great info you have right here on this post. I will be coming back to your site for more soon.

    Reply
  39. Manya Kaushik

    Hello, its my first time to commenting any post. But I could not stop myself from commenting on reading through such a sensible piece of writing.

    Reply
  40. Happy SINGHANIA

    it is hard to come by well-informed people on this subject, but you seem like you know what You are talking about. Thanks

    Reply
  41. Kartik Bhiwapurkar

    The site looks absolutely fantastic. Well done to all involved. Very professional & the navigation is great too. Cheers.

    Reply
  42. KALPESH SHAH

    This is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. I have joined your rss feed and look forward to seeking more of your great post. Also, I have shared your web site in my social networks.

    Reply
  43. Parag Goswami

    I was extremely pleased to find this web site. I need to to thank you for ones time due to this wonderful read.. I definitely really liked every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new information on your website.

    Reply
  44. Rahul Singh

    Thanks for the marvelous posting. I genuinely enjoyed reading it, you are a great author. I will always bookmark your blog and will come back very soon. I want to encourage that you continue your great work,have a nice day.

    Reply
  45. Rashmi singhrathor

    Way cool. Some very valid points. I appreciate you penning this write-up and the rest of the site is also very good.

    Reply
  46. Lohith Chodry

    I quite like reading an article that can make men and women think. Also, thank you for permitting me to comment.

    Reply
  47. Rajat kalra

    Absolutely wonderful, well done everyone, what a great achievement. Here is to the future and success for everyone. Thank you all for your hard work, we know it will be ongoing and trust that you will get the appreciation and credit of putting such brilliant articles on the worldwide web. Looking forward to seeing it grow.

    Reply
  48. Gaurav Prakash

    Excellent weblog right here. Also your site loads up very fast. I want my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

    Reply
  49. Dr.Kewal Raj Dawar

    True picture of our parliament’s functioning is nicely detailed. This is resulting in the scarce resources of the country as well as weakening our democratic system

    Reply
  50. Atul Donde B. Com (Hons) FCA

    Very true picture. This is just one effect of our deterirorating quality of politics. One will need to write another article of such a length. No MLA,MP, or even a Gram Sevak is adequately qualified. There is no measure of thieir lowest degree of immaturity. what to write and what not to write is the question. All selfish interests, that is in short

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>