The Case for Privatising PSBs?

Privatising PSBNot every bank employee is into policy decisions, only General Managers, senior managers and members of the Board. Majority of the staff does routine job like taking deposits, dealing with queries on savings and doing other paperwork. Compare it with the staff at McDonald’s, the largest fast food chain. The staff there as well does a routine job. But compare salaries.

You may consider this as an apple to orange comparison, so for an apple to apple comparison, take an average finance professional in any private sector enterprise. She makes balance sheets, prepares ledgers and does other works pertaining to finance like keeping records of inward and outward remittances. As per industry standards, this employee cannot earn more than INR 25-30 thousand per month. But in PSBs, take SBI or PNB, probationary officers draw salaries to the tune of INR 40-50 thousand a month.

RBI data shows that the wage bill of SBI is 12.7 percent of its income, for other PSBs it is 10.7 percent, however, in case of privately-held banks it is only 8.7 percent.

Banks were nationalized in 1969 for the sole purpose that they serve as bankers to poor Indians and not just to corporates and rich and middle class. Priority sector lending and giving access to banking services to all Indians was the target of nationalisation. Today, the objective is more than achieved. Small Finance Banks and Payment Banks have been given licenses by RBI and they are carving their own niche.

Moreover, project finance, especially in case of infrastructure projects where the gestation period is high, is done mainly by PSBs. But when these projects are stalled due to factors beyond the control of PSBs, their books take a hit.By privatising PSBs, we can make them autonomous in deciding whether to finance big ticket projects or focus on retail lending. Decisions by officials will then be based on financial returns from investments so made, wise decision makers will be incentivised and imprudent ones penalised.

SBI has recently said that it will focus on retail lending to make its books healthier. But can it do so in such an open and competitive market? NBFCs, for past some years, have targeted retail financing and they have taken over virtually the most market. Bajaj Finance allows people to avail quick finance on consumer durables through a mobile application; Tata Finance has been financing car loans. Where do you think is the space for SBI and others to go for retail lending?

Yes they can, but only when they come up with innovative products like Bajaj Finance and it is not possible unless PSBs are privatised and there is provision of incentives for decision makers.

Composition of board committees of PSBs has of late been so altered that now the government nominated director (who usually is an official from Ministry of Finance) is not part of board’s Management Committee, which oversees credit lending functions of bank. Also, till a few years back, the director on the board from The Chartered Accountant category served as chairperson of the Audit Committee of Board. But now the scheme has been so amended that the executive director serves as its chairperson. Both these alterations have deteriorated the functioning of committees with powers given in hands of those who lack expertise in lending.

The power to appoint statutory auditors for auditing of public sector banks is now being exercised by the banks’ managements themselves, a move that has discouraged true and fair audit and has terminated the independence of auditors. Furthermore, nominations filed by Chartered Accountants in elections under shareholder category are, in most cases, straightaway rejected by the election committees of PSBs on instructions from the Ministry of Finance; although these professionals can bring much-needed financial wisdom to the board.

How do you privatise?

This is the most critical part. Do you want foreign institutional investors to buy governmentstake? Or do you want Bank of China or HSBC(UK) or JP Morgan (USA) or Mitsubishi Group (Japan) to take over government’s stake in PSBs? No, this should not happen, at least for the time being.

Because if this happens, the government will face stiff opposition from trade unions and even a one-day strike can cost hundreds or thousands of crores of rupees to the market. Moreover, since PSBs staff is in the habit of working as a government employee, they will not be able to adjust in an environment akin to private sector where punctuality and productivity are the keys to success.

What can be done is to form a government trust, one for each PSB for instance one trust for SBI, called the SBI Investment Trust. Place all government shareholding in SBI in this trust. The trust will have no linkwith any minister or bureaucrat and will be managed by trustees who shall be experts from the fields of finance and banking, such as former CEOs of top banks, from India or abroad, economists and others like members of NITI Aayog, even FICCI and CII.

Which bank to privatize first?

I would say SBI. Yes, to have an impact go for one that is the biggest. I would even criticise SBI merger with its associates last year. What purpose did it serve other than placing SBI in the list of top 50 banks globally by assets? SBI’s branch network is strong, they have maximum exposure to credit and it is the banker to much of India. Go for SBI through the trust model.

The main reasons for privatizing PSBs are:

Governance – Governance in PSBs is broken to the core. From the one at the top to one at the bottom, all staffers go to work just for salaries and not to create or innovate. Governance is so weak that even a branch manager has no supervisory control over his subordinates. I would say there are many frauds that go unreported or underreported; only the massive ones come out in the public domain.

Professionalism –If not financially corrupt, almost every PSB branch is ethically corrupt. No one addresses a customer saying ‘Sir, how can I help you?’ Rather, staffers have the tendency to scold visiting customers and have an inherent intention not to do work. True, there are exceptions to this behavior, but the system is deeply damaged.

Profitability – Profitable, healthier banks are in everyone’s interest – public, government, corporates and even bank employees. With PSBs having such high reported non-performing assets (the hidden ones are still hidden) and other hindrances like high operating costs due to higher wages, you cannot expect profitability from them.

Some key points must be considered

1. In the third quarter of FY 2018, Yes Bank (privately owned) reported a 22 percent increase in its net profit; Kotak Mahindra Bank’s (also privately owned) profit stood at Rs.1053 crore. But the state-owned SBI posted a loss of Rs. 2416 crore for the same period owing to provisions for bad loans.

2. RBI data confirms that while return on equity (ROE) in case of privately-held banks was just under 12 percent, for SBI it was in negative terrain (-0.7 percent) and for other state-owned banks it stood at -2.8 percent in FY 2017.

3. As many as 16 PSBs did not pay dividend in FY 2015-16, which led to a 67 percent fall in the revenues of government of India. Six state-owned banks that did pay dividend paid the same at lower rates compared to past years.

4. Rs.1.45 lakh crore has been earmarked for recapitalisation of public sector banksfor current and next financial year; more than Rs. 1 lakh crore was given to PSBs by the government between 2010-11and 2016-17.

5. PSBs account for more than 70 percent of banking business in the country andin terms of NPAs, they accounted for more than80 percentof total bad assets in FY 2016-17.

Privatisation of PSBs can be the most complex task, especially when the present Modi-led government’s stance appears tilted toward nationalism, of which one can say nationalisation and public sector is a crucial part. Also, trade unions can pose their own set of problems. The trust model as described above thus can be the feasible mid-way.

(The article published in daily newspaper “The Statesman” on 25th February 2018)

The Case for Privatising PSBs?

72 thoughts on “The Case for Privatising PSBs?

  1. Dhananjay sharma

    Everyone has suddenly started to talk about privatising all government banks. Do you think this is even possible? What is the framework to do so and how would you guarantee improved banks after privatisation?

    Reply
  2. Hari Pavan

    Governance issues in public sector banks have been killing profits and allowing fraudsters to loot public money. Unless you make officials accountable, do not expect any improvement.

    Reply
  3. Rajiv Patel

    Government should get out of all businesses. Politicians cannot refrain from interfering and so these businesses are never able to achieve their full potential.

    Reply
  4. Jayant kumar

    When non performing assets climb to double digits, it means that most NPAs are owned by a few corporates. Government should first resolve NPA mess and then think of finding a buyer for stake in PSBs.

    Reply
  5. Naveen Prajapati

    Salaries at lower levels in government banks is high but at the top it is dwarfed as compared to private counterparts. Rationalising salaries across levels is the first step that government should take.

    Reply
  6. Geeta Soneja

    RBI itself was in inaction during the UPA era and could only take cognisance of high bad assets when NDA came to power. Why not first punish RBI officials for their lack of sense of duty.

    Reply
  7. keshav kumar

    PM Modi is a game changer and has capability as well as capacity to initiate bold reforms. Like Atal-led government came up with idea of privatisation, Modi should also do so if banking is to be improved.

    Reply
  8. Mohit Shukla

    Do not expect the current government to take any decisive action on this matter till 2019 elections. This is because they cannot afford enmity with trade unions of banks.

    Reply
  9. karthik sethi

    SBI Chairman has correctly said that why only private companies are in NCLT? Bad governance is more in privately held companies than public sector ones.

    Reply
  10. Gagan Talwar

    The amount is only getting bigger every passing day. Now the scam has reached 2 billion dollars and can rise as investigating agencies find more gaps and illegalities. Let’s pray PNB comes out of this.

    Reply
  11. Hemant Pratap singh

    In case public sector banks reforms include privatisation government will face opposition from employees of these banks. Even one day strike will cost the government so much that they will dump this proposal.

    Reply
  12. Amit Kumar

    Way cool. Some very valid points. I appreciate you penning this write-up and the rest of the site is also very good.

    Reply
  13. Mayank Pandey

    I was inspired by reading your thoughts. And I shall surely be coming back soon to see more of your work.

    Reply
  14. Chokkalingam M

    After looking at a number of the articles on your website, I really appreciate your way of blogging.

    Reply
  15. Maaz Khatib

    I am sure this piece of writing has touched all the internet viewers, its really really pleasant article on building up new weblog.

    Reply
  16. Chitwanjit singh

    Hi there to every one, it is in fact a fastidious for me to go to see this website, it includes important Information.

    Reply
  17. Prasad Mahashabde

    it is very straightforward to find out any topic on net as compared to books, as I found this article at this web site.

    Reply
  18. RAVI GUPTA

    Excellent weblog right here. Also your site loads up very fast. I want my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

    Reply
  19. Manigandan gonda

    Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts. Carry on the great work.

    Reply
  20. Dr MC Singh

    Congratulations for all the effort putten in to reach to such explanatory and efficient article.

    Reply
  21. Ulhas Mandrawadkar

    I was extremely pleased to find this web site. I need to to thank you for ones time due to this wonderful read.. I definitely really liked every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new information on your website.

    Reply
  22. Manoj Agrawal

    This is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. I have joined your rss feed and look forward to seeking more of your great post. Also, I have shared your web site in my social networks.

    Reply
  23. Rudresh kr.Pandey

    Good day. I just would like to give you a big thumbs up for your excellent information you have right here on this post. I will be coming back to your blog for more soon.

    Reply
  24. Esaki Raja

    I am highly impressed with the think tank that you possess. I wonder how 1 man can have so much of knowledge

    Reply
  25. Mrigank Tripathi

    I am often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has actually peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your web site and keep checking for brand new information.

    Reply
  26. Mohit Gupta

    I really appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further write ups thanks once again.

    Reply
  27. Veera Kumaran

    Greetings. Very useful advice in this particular post. it is the little changes which will make the most important changes.Thanks for sharing.

    Reply
  28. PIYUSH KESHARWANI

    I like the valuable information you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I am quite certain I will learn lots of new stuff right here. Best of luck for the next.

    Reply
  29. Uday Veeranki

    A fascinating discussion is worth comment. I do believe that you need to publish more about this subject, it may not be a taboo subject but typically folks do not discuss these subjects. To the next. Many thanks..

    Reply
  30. Da finishers

    Fantastic put up, very informative. I wonder why the opposite experts of this sector do not understand this. You must continue your writing. I am confident, you have a huge readers base already.

    Reply
  31. Avinash Sharma

    Just finished reading your article and wanted to congratulate you on your compelling abilities. Good luck for the future work.

    Reply
  32. Ken Vaidya

    You are very intelligent. You already know the significance in the case of this matter. You post consider numerous angles of information. Your own stuff is excellent.

    Reply
  33. Akash gupta

    Just spent a few very enjoyable minutes looking at the site. Excellent. Well done. Overall very good: clean, easy to navigate, informative and, importantly, interesting.

    Reply
  34. Aman Wadhwa

    Hello very cool website. Man .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your website and take the feeds additionally.I am glad to search out numerous useful information here within the publish, we need work out extra techniques in this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .

    Reply
  35. Siddharth T.C.

    Your style is very unique compared to other people I have read stuff from. Thanks for posting when you have got the opportunity.

    Reply
  36. Mahath Mohan

    Hello there. This blog post could not be written much better. Going through this article reminds me of my previous roommate. He constantly kept talking about this. I will send this information to him. Fairly certain he will have a very good read. I appreciate you for sharing.

    Reply
  37. Macky bhatia

    Hi friends, nice piece of writing and good arguments commented at this place, I am in fact enjoying by these.

    Reply
  38. Corli de

    I do accept as true with all of the ideas you have introduced for your post. They are very convincing and will certainly work.Thank you for the post.

    Reply
  39. Keshav Mishra

    We look forward to reading many more thoughts of yours , and wish you the success that you deserve.

    Reply
  40. Jeet Pipalia

    Ahaa, its pleasant dialogue about this piece of writing at this place at this weblog, I have read all that, so at this time me also commenting here.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *